Hi fi,
I got back from the Istankoy earlier today, it was great!
Location was ideal for us, wasn't right smack dab in the centre but was only a two minute stroll down the back street till you were on the sea front (the hub of the action) It meant you could sleep at night without being interrupted yet all the action is on the doorstep...and we didn't get woken by the daily prayers at any point either, always a bonus!
The hotel itself was alright, pool and all the areas were very clean, though our room resembled a box more than hotel rooms we've been to before. There was only a small window and no balcony. Didn't cause as much problems as we initially though it was, just meant to got up and went up, sampleing the Bodrum sights rather than sitting on the balcony.
The staff are extremely friendly, though I'd suggest putting all you things in the safety deposit boxes at reception, as my phone was stolen from the room. The management were helpful, but said they couldn't work out who it was.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6adca/6adca998870a786948475b94fd636d03f025bb6e" alt=":?"
It didn't affect the holiday overall though, not much could have.
I think there was entertainment at the hotel most night (one being a typical turkish night with belly dancing, break dancing and turkish folk dancing) though we didn't go to any of these as we tended to explore the area. Though it always seemed busy.
We didn't have a rep either, but there was a 24 hour help-line which promised to have a rep with you in a short time if there was any problems (which we didn't have, except the theft of the phone which was sorted without them) . I'd definately recommend going on the 'welcome day tour' basically a welcome meeting but done in a bar in Gumbet.
I'd also reccomend going on a boat trip with 'BodEX' (it located just over the road from the Istankoy on the right hand side) Was half the price of the Thomson one, and only had around 15 people on it, a lot nicer than a few we saw that were packed like sardines!
There is a review somewhere on the net, thats why we chose that over the Kilavuz (sp?) I'll try and find it for you.
Hope this helps, I just read over it and it seems like I'm moaning on. I'm not, and apparently some of the rooms have balconys so you may get one.
Such a good holiday, and the hotel was fine for what we needed it for. Can't wait to go back, and I'd definately stay at the Istankoy again!
Amy