we have stayed at the ICD and at the Ocean Sand and Golf Punta Cana, both were fantastic hotels, the beach in PC defo better, but IMHO there was a lot more to do outside the resort in the North ie the waterfalls,cable car ride up the mountain,white water rafting, I suppose it depends what you want from your holiday
Debi

Yes, thats my problem. I hate to be confined to the hotel and although dreams is massive, Its mainly just rooms from what I gather.

Still havent decided but starting to sway more towards the ones in the north.