Hi
I have been to both Benidorm ( last Year) and loads of times to Magaluf, Even stayed in the Magaluf Park in March this year.
Although Magaluf can be rowdy , you can also find lots of good bars with entertainment on eg: Manos , jokers, Fountain.
I found Benidorm Too noisy for me and that was in May,.
I much prefer magaluf

hia we to liked benidorm and i took me missus and a 16yr old to magaluf last year at the end of july and she insisted we book again we had a great time last year i dont no if its me but it seems a bit more relaxed in magaluf. the square behind the bcm nightclub is buzzing everynight with free entertainment (hypnotist, dancers and acrobats) outside till midnight, and you will also be entertained by the fancy dressess of all the stags an hens. like mags says manos is very good. oh an the 17 yr old wants to come with us again !

The Magalluf Park Hotel is not normally a Hotel where the Stag and Hen groups would stay. It's on the Palma Nova side of town, and only a short walk down to the quieter beaches in Palma Nova, but as previous posters have said, it's very near to BCM Square, where they have live entertainment until Midnight, Fountain Bar is just across the road, and I think they are starting entertainment at the House of Kathmandu, which the Mag Park overlooks.

I went to Benidorm in December, and had a lovely break, but there we always felt we had to be on our guard on the streets with so many beggars and Gypsies on the streets, which you simply do not get in Magalluf. The PR's in Magalluf have definitely been banned, and walking the streets, both day and night is a much more pleasant and relaxed affair, in my opinion.

Cheers

Adam