Hi Enchanted
have been to both and Riva del Garda / Limone as well. We have reviews about our hotel at Bardolino , the Gritti. We have also stayed at The Eurpoa in Riva del Garda.
Both are great : if you want scenery and mountains then head for Malcesine - a superb town, a fabulous castle, the cable to the mountain top and in easy reasch of Riva del Garda (stunning) and Limone - ditto. Bardolino is beautiful and in easy reach of Sirmione (and castle and town) and Verona and the Opera are closer -
Personally if we went back we would go to Riva or Limone ----- or Malcesine. All are at the top end of the lake and if you want to you can visit the bottom (flatter) end. The Northern end (Malcesine) is scenically stunning!
Riva is stunning - we stayed at the Best Western Europa and that was a fantastic experience (please ask if you want ideas). We have visited Limone and if (when) we return to the area we would go there. Malcesine is great too and within easy reach of all of the others.
For us , we have done both and we agree that though both Bardolino and Sirmione are nice, the towns of the Northern end are lovely we would return to the mountains time and time again -
Any questions just pm us
PS The hotel we stayed at in Riva is called the Best Western Europa and is right on the quay side with stunning, amazing views over the area - have a look on their web site via Best Western - you wont be disappointed.