Yeah i'm just trying to balance things out for the original poster. A lot of things with regards Hotels are very subjective, plus things can indeed change quite substantially from when someone last stayed at the Hotel. I've noticed that in the main, the Pelicanos does get good reviews, its about 47th out of over 200 on Tripadvisor, based on a large number of reviews. Quite often people only post reviews when they've something negative to say, so based on what the majority have been saying, it seems a decent enough hotel in which to have a holiday. Personally it would be to large a Hotel, and too British orientated for my tastes, but my tastes arn't everyones, so i can understand why some people would like to give this hotel a try.
Guess you've got to take comments on board, read between the lines, and come to your own decision as to whether any particular hotel seems like it might be suitable for your needs. I read quite a number of negative comments about the Mont Park, before i made a considered judgement, and decided to stay there. I really enjoyed it, and will be staying there again in Sept.
Best Regards - Taggy