We stayed at Captain Silver last August(booked through Icmeler Online - Brilliant!)
We were more than happy with accom,pool & location etc.
We went out each evening, only drank in th bar there once, and yes it was too quiet for us, plenty to choose from in town though, especially the Wonderboys pub, only a few minutes walk.
We would defintely stay there on our next visit, although we would have a 2 bed apartment, the one bed was a bit small for 2 ad & 2 ch
Have a great time, I know you will!