I only speak as I find ...and have to say this ship was all I expected and more for value, cleanliness, friendliness, Entertainment and the shore excursions where reasonably priced. For e.g this year I have booked a Royal Carribean Cruise as it was recommended to me, and have emailed them 3 x with a quiestion and had no reply other than the standard email, "we have received your email and someone will email you within the next 24/48 hours". I booked through Vacations to go and emailed them to tell them what I wanted, I had a reply the same day of them...they had a very quick responce of Royal! possibly because thats who they sell there cabins through?? who knows.
When on Island Escape I was instantly responded to! The small ship seems to have the more personal touch. Also the excursions on Royal Carribean are expensive, they are very overpriced for e.g Rome (like for like) £50 Island £110 Royal Carribean!
I can't comment on whether or not Royal Carribean is the better holiday for us yet as I haven't sailed on her yet, but would be happy to be going back on Island Escape this year...only booked Royal as it was £100 cheaper than I/E and have to say they get there money back on trips, spa and hairdressing and drinks in comparison to Island.
Enjoy go for it as you won't be disappointed.
Liz