data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1842c/1842cbc8a012b19bcc63528c3250c1e8049e1a2b" alt=":wave:"
LOL Dont know if I can sell it to you Michelle. We really liked it, different to Sharm of course.
Seems to be owned by two guys who kind of invented it as a hassle free resort about 15 years ago & arranged for construction 5, 4 and 3 star hotels around lagoons. Very pretty, but no coral if that's your thing.
There are a couple of hubs with many restaurants, bars & shops. Downtown & the marina, I think they have built a 2nd marina but we didnt have time to find it.
Maybe if you're not 100% you could try it for a week ? Although I don't know if you only do a week
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/baf91/baf91857f74550e66a8f32f71f5c0451dd331f3f" alt=":rofl"
.
There is the Movenpick which is a 5* & does AI, HB BnB. A Sheraton & a Steignberer Golf.
The Three Corners Rihana (family orientated) & Three Corners Ocean view (adult orientated) - I saw the later and it looked nice, near one of the marinas. Both 4* AI.
Not sure which ones would equate to a similar experience to that which you enjoy at the Sonesta Beach ? Only way of finding out is probably ploughing through the reviews on the opposition. There are lots of water based trips.
Here are a few links:
http://www.longwoodholidays.co.uk
http://www.redseaholidays.co.uk
http://www.thomascookstyle.com
http://www.thomascook.com
http://www.directholidays.co.uk
http://www.travelrepublic.co.uk - not sure if you do dynamic packages, but they do El Gouna
Red sea holidays do hotels called the Mosaique and Fanadir which I think are small boutique hotels.
We went with Thomas Cook Style, as you got a free meal & extra luggage for the same price as Thomas Cook ordinary. Thomson don't seem to carry El Gouna for some reason.
T'other thing you could do is book an easyjet flight to Hurgada & then a hotel direct (if you can find out how) or book hotel with the likes of travel republic or other bed booker.
This site is quite good, although it is obviously a sales pitch for El Gouna as it is the offical site, but it lists all the hotels.
http://www.elgouna.com
Not sure how you determine no hassle, they dont follow you down the street like they do in naama bay, but DD who was with, got fed up going to the pool bar to get water/drinks as the waiters kept ' hittin on her' as she so charmingly puts it. I explained at the time we were there it was mainly young families, couples & olds like me n her Dad, so there weren't many young women on their own.
As you like a bit of life outside your hotel it is probably a better bet than Makadi Bay for you, plus there is Hurgarda itself, although on leaving the airport it looks a bit bleak but when you get in properly there are probably some lovely hotels about.
Doe