I go to both Icmeler and Zante every year and I really love both of them but if I had to choose I would pick Icmeler its such a lovely place it may have a longer transfer but it is worth it. The place is surrounded with pine tree and I think it has a magical feel about it and the Turkish people are so friendly which I find Zante is missing nowadays, and you dont get the earthquakes that you get in Zante.
Yeah, I must admit, without wanting to be unkind to the island 'cos I
did meet some very nice people there, but of all the Greek islands ive visited, I found Zante to be the least welcoming.Maybe I was just unlucky?
As for Turkey, ive just recently returned from Marmaris,my first trip to that country.We absolutely loved it, and after a visit to Icmeler, we became enchanted by the resort....And I wouldnt be too put off by the hassle from the locals - once you politely but firmly let them know you arent interested, they leave you alone, trust me