Wow !!! Darren those are great photos, and Rodney Bay is looking more & more like the hot favourite than ever now.
Thank you so much for taking the trouble to post those pictures (my daughter loved the Puffers by the way !).
Personally, I'd much rather see dolphins in the wild, so a boat trip sounds like a must do.
It all sounds fantastic.....and the more I think about it, I'm sure we will want to do more than sit on a beach eating & drinking for a week in a remote AI hotel..... when by your account, St Lucia is such a beatiful island and has so much to offer.
I'd love to go diving again (I did a Padi equivalent qualification many years ago in Egypt) and have my son do a course too before we go, but I'm a little worried about his age and the effects on his lungs of the gas in the tanks - he is only 11 years old and small for his age at that.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/66552/66552aebce2145e1580a1599aae03a13e4856304" alt=":think"
.......perhaps I'm just being daft though, I've no real basis for thinking that way ....
Just in case... do you have any recommendations for dive schools who would be willing to take a couple of novices out... and that are based in, or around, Rodney Bay ? (subject to some pre-dive lessons in the UK for both of us of course).