Hi
Just wanted to add our, admittedly biased, voice to the discussion. Things been so busy lately we can't always get onto this forum as often as we'd like. But if you are cosidering various places for a wedding we'd also recommend the Dominican Republic - it has a wealth of attractions, places to visit, things to see, from historic relics and buildings, to spectacular landscapes.
We have added a checklist of things to consider when arranging a wedding in the Caribbean on our free-info site my sister and I have been developing - so I hope it may be of some interest/help in making successful plans for your big day wherever you choose in the Caribbean!(the page is listed on the left hand contents bar of the home page - see sig file)
Just a quick note about 'extreme weather' - As far as hurricanes go - they are a fact of life in the Caribbean although severe and damaging hurricanes are relatively rare. The stronger winds and storms tend to occur from September through end November (so this is the best time to avoid visiting the Caribbean to reduce the odds of experiencing the worst) - although it is true that the 'season' begins much earlier as one respondent points out.
(
Note: The odds are that at some time all parts of the Caribbean - which is in the World's 'hurricane belt' - will occasionally suffer at the hands of a 'stronger than usual' storm...This would mean that places that have suffered recently, according to probability, are LESS likely to suffer again anytime soon, whereas those places that have not seen hurricanes for many years are statistically MORE likely to suffer in the nearer future.
It always amazes us that some folks who get caught up in a storm, afterwards say..."but it hadn't happened for 50 years" as if this should make a place safer...statistically it MUST be riskier! Just a thought, to address the suggestion that longer periods without hurricanes are a 'good' thing - when of course according to the Stats it must in fact be the reverse!
BUT naturally whilst predicting exactly where hurricanes will make landfall is almost impossible - for instance, we KNEW months in advance that it would be a bad year - well before New Orleans got hit...because the NOAA hurricane forecasting center had noted the exact weather patterns occurring just as they did before the terrible storms of the 1930's (Which makes it even more amazing how badly prepared the US was to cope!): You can keep in touch with predictions here when thinking of pre-booking:
http://www.nhc.noaa.gov/)
Our favorite time in the DR is January through March - but I realize this period will not always suit everyone's wedding plans! Nonetheless we think its the nicest time of year if you can book then.
Wherever you decide to have your happy day - we wish you all the very best
Ruth (bizzy)