Reviews on following link

http://www.holidaytruths.co.uk/reviews/spain/balearic-islands/menorca/cala-n-porter/

HTH
Biff

Binibeca no i wouldnt.
But cala en porter yes its a great place to go to.
We have been to menorca 5 times 4 times to the cala en forcat area when the kids were younger and october 2005 we rented a villa at porter for two weeks.
Fantastic,the best holiday we have ever had.
The resort is not a very noisy one,sapiasa on the cross roads has open air entertainment most nights till aprox 12pm but its not in your face if you know what i mean.Our villa wasnt far away from the centre but we could hardley hear any noise if we returned early.
VIlla holidays are great because of the privacy but dont stay around the pool all day get down to the beach its very nice and the waters fantastic.
I have actualy just booked today two weeks in october,couldnt afford it last year so we cant wait.
Hope this helps Regards Mark