I usually take a one week holiday in the spring at home here in Scotland - and we have actually been very lucky with the weather most of the time. One year on Skye we all had to go shopping for lighter clothes because it was so hot. We usually pay around £350, £400 for something extra special, for a 3 bedroom cottage during the school April break. They have always been much better equipped than anything we've booked abroad. We usually eat out most evenings and if we pay more than £15 a head including wine then we've pushed the boat out. I live in Scotland so my travel costs are minimal. even for getting to the northwest Highlands but the other 3 don't but even so I reckon the total cost (= cottage rental, all food, all transport there) for 4 adults rarely exceeds £1,000 pounds all in. Admittedly we aren't looking for much in the way of evening entertainment beyond a nice meal and some decent wine to drink while we admire the view (one of the 'musts' for any cottage we book!). I tend to stock up on wine inadvance, buying on offer and putting it to one side - it's one of the bonuses of going SC at home - I can save money by taking 'treats' like this with us.
During the October school break we usually go to La Gomera in the Canaries. There we are paying 350 Euros for our accommodation, cheaper but the apartment only has 2 bedrooms which means that my friend and I have to share and we have to remember to pack the earplugs! It's very, very basic and whilst in a lovely setting it is far worse value than we get at home - even more so given the exchange rate. The travel costs are much, much higher though. My parents are retired and can go on holiday at any time but my friend and I work in jobs where we have don't have that much flexiblity and also cannot book to far in advance.Also, the need to book flights that will enable good connection times for the ferry over to La Goemra from Los Christianos reduces the options.
So this year, the travel costs alone will exceed £1,000 by the time you add in the costs of us all getting to the same departure point in the UK - I live in Scotland, my parents live in Liverpool and my friend in Sussex. This year I'm travelling down to travel from Manchester to keep the journey simple for my elderly parents, whilst my friend will fly out from Gatwick. We're hoping that neither flight will be delayed as the costs will escalate if we have to get involved in travelling on different ferries etc. We don't bother taking out travel insurance for the Scottish holiday but wouldn't risk it abroad. So now that they are both turned 80 and my mother has a complicated health history, this alone is adding an extra £140 to the cost. We are expecting that this year eating out will cost around the same as it does here in Scotland with the result that I expect that in total this week will cost us approaching £2,000 in total for 4 adults. Yes, we will benefit from guaranteed sunshine and that is why we go - it gives us all a good sunshine boost before the winter, but apart from the sunshine we are paying close to double what we would to do very much the same things as we do in Scotland in the spring.
Yes, I am sure we could go on an October break to mainland Spain for much cheaper but the large scale resorts aren't our cup of tea nor do we want to be tied down to a HB deal in a hotel. And if we had to share a room in hotel without extra living space I doubt that my friend and I would remain friends for long! And 2 single supplements would bump the cost too. I'm not complaining - we pay to get the sort of holiday we want and we still consider it good value - we wouldn't keep going back again if we didn't - but the similar sort of holiday in Scotland costs us much much less.
This year we didn't have the usual spring break in Scotland - we couldn't co-ordinate dates and instead I went to Seville with 2 other friends where a 2 bedroom apartment during the Feria cost 900 Euros! Add on flights and a much higher cost of living due to the exchange rate and we probably didn't get much change out of £500 per head for that trip either. I'm not convinced that, for the sort of holiday I enjoy, it is automatically cheaper abroad - and the Cuban trips certainly aren't! But I happily spend a total of £2,000 a time for those because they are such a unique experience and one I simply couldn't get any other way or in any other place at that sort of price.
SM
PS. Realise that I and others have been led a bit astray from the original topic! But I think that the point, or at least my point, is that surely we all make our decisions about when and where to holiday on more grounds than just cost alone? I can holiday cheaper in the UK than in La Gomera but like that guaranteed sunshine in the Autumn. A dance holiday with the quality of tuition I get in Cuba would actually probably cost me more here given that what amounts to private lessons here cost upwards of £50 an hour with a decent professional - that would add up to £1,500 in tution alone!