Very nicely reasoned, Net Detective!
I guess the answer to your question would be 'No-one - at least no-one in their right mind'!
I can't understand people rubbishing All-Inclusive holidays in favour of Room Only, B&B, Half Board or Full Board.
Nor can I understand people rubbbishing particular resorts.
The bottom line is:
we are all different, we have different requirements and expectations from a holiday - so why not leave people to choose exactly the type of holiday, destination and board arrangements that suits them.
If people ask for advice on the pros and cons of AI, then fine - advise away.
But don't try to change what other people prefer to do, just because it's
your preference.
AI doesn't suit
us, just as a very busy 18-30 resort wouldn't suit
us.
But, I wouldn't presume to recommend to those young 20-somethings that they should go to Nerja or Sicily or Lesvos, instead of Kavos or Faliraki.