I have stayed in several places which have had a mixed bunch of reviews and often some really worrying comments, but we've always had a fantastic time. The worst hotel we stayed in was the Gran Hotel Casino Royal in Lloret de Mar (it was on "Holidays Undercover" a couple of weeks ago), it was hot and stuffy, and
very noisy, but we met lots of great people and that was what made it a good holiday for us.
You can often form an opinion of the person writing the review just from the comments they make, and then you can see what sort of thing would appeal to that sort of person, if you know what I mean. Sometimes people can make really bad comments about the food or the entertainment or the rooms, but you can often tell from the tone of the review whether they're the type of people who complain about everything. Sometimes you see reviews that say "it was brill - lots of booze, music, and a good laugh..." these are the type of people who only go on holiday to eat and drink as much as they can and may not take too much notice of things that other people would consider a problem.
It is difficult to write a balanced review, and it's difficult to decide whether to book a particular place when the reviews are vastly different from one family to the next. However, all reviews are helpful and I'm very grateful to all the people who take the time to write them, whether good or bad.
Now, I really must get on with writing my review....