It was my first sea cruise so cant compare to other ships, I was aprehensive after reading the recent reviews in particular the problems in the Med. However the itinerary was the reason I booked the cruise.
My experience was good, I found the ship to be clean, the food good, the crew very pleasant the entertainment varied and good. I spent quite a bit on excursions booked on board mainly for those involving activities but also went ashore to book the local site seeing trips which are considerably cheaper than those booked on the ship.
I spoke to a number of people who had been on teen on the ship in the Med and most said that the ship had been put into service too soon after being transferred from the previous owners Costa Cruises but it had not been so traumatic to prevent them re booking.
The only problem I noticed from the previous complaints was the 'smell issue' it has been said that there is a smell of sewage. I didn't smell sewage but did notice at times a chemical smell on stairwell 'B' but didn't hear any complaints from those with cabins nearby.
The only complaint I would have is that bottled water is not provided free even if you are on A.I.
I also found it strange that the sliding roof over the Sirens pool deck was not used (We did have 1 day of torrential rain)
If you accept that this ship 1s 20 odd years old and don't compare it to the Super Luxurious modern ships I think you will have a great holiday I will certainly consider it for any future cruise