Hi Lyn
I seem to be following you around the world (well Europe anyway

). trouble is my shortlist is a long list!
The reviews are still excellent, I am keen to go somewhere that will keep the kids entertained and will hopefully attract older children, and the idea of a 2 hour flight appeals. I know that San Miguel is small but we would probably have a car for the middle part of the holiday.
I did notice in the Thomson brochure that the Beach Club bit is only 2*, with both of the hotels being 3*, but I guess that refers to the rooms being basic, because the feedback scores are good and it seems the food is still good.