Just flown back from Florida with first choice star class premier today, the flight out was fine we boarded before everyone else had a champagne and strawberries, we got the seats we wanted 2 in front and 2 behind the food was nice starter with melon then you had a choice of chicken, beef or a veggie option we all asked for the beef, but there wasn't enough to go around so 2 of us had to pick again I had the chicken which was nice.

The flight back was ok we may as well as been in the normal seats as we didn't have priority boarding everyone just went on at the same time there was no call for us first or when we got off the plane at Manchester.
This flight was a bad one really we were in seats where there was brown water dripping from the cupboard above onto my hubby shoulder its has stained his top, they did what they could but for the first 15 minutes into the flight it was drip drip, they said it was condensation but I don't know . The crew were really nice about it and we're not one for complaining but having to sit under this drip drip holding a handful of tissues above you is not a brilliant start to a flight, a member of the crew said it always happens on take off and landing 'sorry not much we can do'. They have asked us for our details and going to send us a voucher for the cleaning of the top it was an O'Neal t-shirt £30 worth I hope it come out
The food on the way home was the same not enough beef 2 of us had to choose again, this was fine the food was nice for aircraft food

On the whole I wouldn't pay for an upgrade with first choice again not worth it really, I went for a walk in to the star class seat which are 33" pitch as to 36" and the seats looked much more comfortable you could lift up the armrest and lie down if you wanted.

First choice is no different then any other company I didn't feel 'wow' it was just 'ok' we were also delayed 4 hour departing from Manchester.
I will travel with them again but keep my money for the upgrade to spend on something else.
Ali